Mrs. E. G. Greene, the W.C.T.U., and kindergartens in
Santa Cruz, 1885-1899
Introduction
The WomanÕs Christian
Temperance Union is one of those astounding organizations which from time to
time in American history has quickly gathered huge number of members and swept
across the country, making itself known, heard, and even feared almost
everywhere. Beginning in 1874 in
Chautauqua, New York, the ladies of the W.C.T.U. were fighting the use of
liquor as far away as California by 1879.
They did not accomplish this without strong leaders, most notably their
second president and most potent organizer, Frances Willard. There were many others as well. One was Mary J. Greene, that is, Mrs.
E. G., Greene, who combined her national activities as a pioneer in the promotion
of kindergartens in the United States with her dynamic local presence in Santa
Cruz. The present essay is not the
complete history of her life, but is, rather, the story of an extraordinary
woman in Santa Cruz.
Origins in Vermont
Mary J. Wright was born in
Poultney, Vermont in 1841. Her
father, William, had been born in Scotland; her mother, Jerusha, was born in
Vermont. (1) About 1843 William
Wright and his family moved from Poultney in southern Vermont to St. Albans in
the northern part of the state. Mary J. received a classical education in
Castleton Seminary [in southern Vermont] and taught high school in St. Albans. In 1865 she married Edward. G. Greene in
St. Albans. They had two children, both of whom died in infancy. (2)
Edward was born in 1834 in St.
Albans of parents also born in Vermont. (3) The ÒGÓ in his name stood for Griswold, (4) although this name appears in no document discovered in the preparation of the present article. He referred to himself as E. G. in all
the documents and articles used to prepare this article except property deeds,
in which he expanded the E. to Edward.
Greenes were plentiful in St.
Albans around 1880. E. GÕs
grandfather, Job Greene, and his grandfatherÕs brother, Nathan Greene, had
settled there in 1786. Both had
many children, including JobÕs son Orrin, E. GÕs father. (5) Although Edward G. was the oldest of
OrrinÕs 11 children, his widowed mother was still alive in 1892. (6) The
mother, Phebe Clark Greene, (7) was living with another of her children in St.
Albans in 1880. (8))
In 1865 E. G. Greene and S.
C. Greene opened a stove, range, furnace, and miscellanies store in St. Albans.
In 1884, however, an A. W. Clark. replaced
E. G. Greene (9) As time went on
E. G. Greene also dealt in real estate in the U. S. West (not California at
that time). From 1870 to 1882 he
was a St. Albans Selectman, in 1878 he was elected to the Vermont Legislature,
and in 1884 he was elected to the Vermont State Senate. (10)
For the first twenty years of
their marriage Mr. and Mrs. E. G. Greene continued to live in St. Albans. According to the 1880 U. S. Census,
Edward G. Greene, age 45, born in Vermont, parents born in Vermont, stove
dealer, was living in a residential hotel in St. Albans, Vermont. Jane Greene, age 39, born in Vermont,
her father born in Scotland, her mother born in Vermont, no occupation, was
listed at the same address and next to Edward G. Greene. Both are listed as Òsingle.Ó The hand-written Census enumeration
clearly gives the name as ÒJane;Ó
the checkmarks in the marital staus column clearly indicate that the two
are single. Nevertheless, their
proximity in the hotel, their ages, the origins of them and their parents, and
the entrepreneurial character of Edward leave no reason to doubt that they are
the Mr. and Mrs. E. G. Greene of this essay.
Mrs. Greene became a
prominent member of the W.C.T.U. while she was still in Vermont. She was the State Secretary for four
years and then the State President for four more years. While in Vermont she wrote the book, Pathfinders for the organization and work of
the WomanÕs Christian Temperance Union. (11)
In addition to being a strong
organizational person for the W.C.T.U., Mrs. Greene also enriched it with her
deep interest in the American kindergarten movement. The notion of the kindergarten as a place where teaching
methods were adapted to children rather than children adapted to the
traditional teaching methods had been championed by Friedrich Froebel in
Germany in the 1830s. The first
American kindergarten was established in 1856 in Wisconsin. Its language was German. The first English language kindergarten
in the U. S. was founded in 1860 in Boston by the outstanding educator and
transcendentalist Elizabeth Peabody.
Receiving her training for the
organization of kindergartens in New York, (12) Mrs. Greene became the
W.C.T.U.Õs first National Superintendent of Kindergarten Work in 1884, when its
Department of Kindergarten Work was instituted. (13) At that time kindergartens were not part of the public school
system, but were run privately or by organizations such as churches, much as
preschools are at present. Thus
the W.C.T.U., which paid great attention to the education of youth, was a
logical provider of information about organizing kindergartens and of education
for kindergarten teachers. Mrs.
GreeneÕs article, ÒThe Kindergarten and the Sunday
School,Ó illustrates the first function and her article, ÒEssential education for WomenÓ illustrates the second. (See Appendix for the text of the
articles.)
Move to Santa Cruz
In 1885, the very year
following her assumption of the national office, Mrs. Greene, although
retaining her responsibilities, moved all the way across the continent: ÒThe address of Mrs. E. G. Greene,
National Superintendent of Kindergarten Work, is for the present, Santa Cruz,
California.Ó (14)
It is not clear that the Greenes particularly wanted
to come to Santa Cruz to live.
They were drawn there by the circumstance of the death of Allan Wright,
William WrightÕs brother and Mary J.Õs uncle.
Allan Gilmore Wright, born in
Scotland, settled in Santa Cruz in 1853. His wife, Rosaline Strong Wright, born in Vermont, died
childless in 1858 in Santa Cruz. (15) Alan was an early property owner on the near west side of
Santa Cruz, having 39.147 acres on Mission Street. (16) The house he started to build on the
property in 1870 was located between present Rigg and Laurel Streets. (17)
In June, 1885 Allan Wright
died in Santa Cruz. (18) He was an
unusual man, who in 1864 had applied for a patent on an improvement on farm
cultivators. (19) Dubbed ÒCrazy WrightÓ because of his eccentricities, he left
the unfinished house and Òtwenty [sic] acresÓ of land on Mission street with a
$1,700 mortgage to M. A. Meder. He
had a living sister in Canada and a living brother [William] in Vermont. (20) Since Allan did not have children his brother
and sister and numerous nieces and nephews had claims to the property. In a complex series of deeds, which was
not completed until 1887, the ownership of 28.8 acres of land owned by Allan,
between Mission and King Streets, from Laurel Avenue east, was transferred to
Mr. E. G. Greene. (21)
Both Greenes, Mary J.Õs
father, William, one of her sisters (Elizabeth or Frances), and her grandniece,
Frances Matilda, daughter of her aunt in Canada, moved to Santa Cruz. They then lived in the house Allan had
begun to build years earlier [at 347 Mission Street] and was now enlarged and
completed with notably high quality workmanship. Mr. E. G. had an office on the first floor and Mrs. E.
G had a Òa
pleasant little studyÓ on the second floor. (22) The house was later ÒoccupiedÓ by Joseph Enright, son of an early
Santa Cruz immigrant Enright. It
was torn down ÒA dozen years ago.Ó (23)
Mrs. E. G. GreeneÕs W.C.T.U. activities in Santa Cruz
Visiting Santa Cruz in 1883,
Frances Willard herself organized the Santa Cruz Union. (24) Mrs. Greene
arrived only two years later and she quickly established herself as a resource
person and a leader for the W.C.T.U. in Santa Cruz, Monterey, and San Benito
Counties, a role which she retained for many years. (25)
The following chronology of Mrs. GreeneÕs W.C.T.U.
talks, trips, and articles has been assembled from firsthand sources, local and
national. Clearly it represents
only a sample of this busy ladyÕs agenda.
1886
In April the W.C.T.U. weekly newspaper, The Union Signal, printed an article
about Mrs. E. G. GreeneÕs class for kindergarten teachers. At the first meeting she spoke about
educational methods in various cultures.
In the main she followed the recently published History of Pedagogy of Gabriel CompayrŽ, translated by W. H. Payne.
The second class consisted of a quiz on the readings of the first, with such
questions as, ÒGive a brief account of French pedagogy,Ó ÒMention distinctive
features of Hindoo system,Ó What place in the education of the individual did
Plato give to the soul? ÒWhat did Charlemagne give to education?Ó and ÒGive
history of the founding of the Kindergarten by Froebel.Ó (text in appendix)
In September it was reported that ÒMrs. E. G. Greene,
of this place, spoke at Chico on the evening of the 19th, on the
topic, ÔShall our children be free?Õ under the auspices of the W.C.T.U.Ó (26)
1887
In March, upon her return from the East, where she
was Òhonored with large and appreciative audiences,Ó Mrs. E. G. Greene was to
speak at the W.C.T.U. meeting of March 17. (27)
Mrs. Greene was not reelected at the end of her term as
President of the Santa Cruz Union in September because she was going for Óa few
months visit to the East.Ó As she
relinquished the presidency, it was noted that Òfrom her long experience in the
work she was peculiarly qualified and ever ready to give us words of
encouragement sympathy or instruction as she saw our need of them.Ó (28)
1888
Mrs. GreeneÕs article,ÒEssential Education for Women,Ó
appeared in the May issue of the national publication The Kindergarten for Teachers and Parents. In it she argued that women are
eminently suited by nature to teach with the methods of Froebel. Furthermore, ÒThis
century will place the early education of the child where it belongs, and woman
will take her place as the acknowledged educator.Ó ÒHence no effort should be spared to bring the knowledge of
the Kindergarten to young women; it belongs to them, it is their heritage;
their profession.Ó (text in appendix)
In June it was reported thatÒMrs. E. G. Greene,
National Superintendent of Kindergarten Department of the W.C.T.U., and author
of ÒGolden KeysÓ (elsewhere noticed)[see below], is having a delightful time
with Miss Cora L. Stockham Ôof oursÕ visiting the Kindergartens of the East. They
are cordially welcomed and receive every courtesy. By invitation of Mrs. McBride, Secretary of the
International WomanÕs Press Asssociation, they attended the New England WomanÕs
Press Club, May 15th, at Boston. Mrs. A. E. Whittaker read a very instructiv [sic] paper
on ÒOportunities of Women in
Journalism.Ó An interesting
discussion followed. Mrs. Ormiston
Chant, of England, gave a bit of her American experience in her usual charming
manner. Mrs. Greene was invited to
present her department of work, and Miss Stockham to talk of THE KINDERGARTEN.
[Miss Stockham was its editor.] The interest shown was truly gratifying.Ó (29)
In the same month of June Mrs. E. G. GreeneÕs book, Golden Keys, was published. An article in the The Kindergarten for Teachers and Parents tells about the book:
ÒTEMPERANCE KINDERGARTEN: Mrs. E. G. Greene, Santa
Cruz, California, is superintendent of this department of W.C.T.U. work. Its aims are to bring to the mothers a
knowledge of the Froebel method of instruction, and to interest them in its use
in the home; also to establish kindergarten schools and to introduce temperance
instruction wherever this system is used.
In addition to these methods, efforts will be made to interest young
ladies to prepare thmselves to become teachers in Kindergarten schools. Mrs. Greene has just issued a Manual of
Hints and Helps, entitled GOLDEN KEYS.
It is intended for all who work for children, for all who are interested
in young women and for all mothers.Ó (30)
In October The
Kindergarten for Teachers and Parents printed another article by Mrs.
Greene, ÒThe Kindergarten and the Sunday School.Ó Briefly, in the words of the article, ÒThe Sunday-school
relates itself to the child more tenderly, takes it more lovingly by the hand,
draws it more closely to the heart, and holds it nearer and dearer, than any
institution outside of the home.Ó
Therefore, she argued, ÒThe Sunday-school holds the golden opportunity
for the spiritual culture of the child, which there brings to the teacher its
best self, seeking nourishment.Ó
She also observed that ÒThe threefold nature of the child must be
trained into equipoise. The health
of the body, the vigor of the intellect, the spontaneity of the soul must
together govern the conduct.Ó This
training, however, Òis the work of the Kindergarten.Ó And so, the Kindergarten Òlooks hopefully toward the
Sunday-school, as a co-worker in this complete education.Ó (text in appendix.)
1891
Mrs. GreeneÕs article, ÒThe School of Methods,Ó a
lengthy account of a three-week summer school for teachers in San Jose,
appeared in the Daily Surf in July. In addition to lectures and symposia, the teachers were given
field trips to the Lick Astronomical Observatory and to Stanford
University. (text in appendix)
1892
The brief history of the W.C.T.U. in Santa Cruz
County in E. S. HarrisonÕs 1892 book, History
of Santa Cruz County, California, pages 208-209, was written by Mrs. E. G.
Greene herself.
Mrs. E. G. Greene resigned as National Kindergarten
Superintendent. (31) There were
six W.C.T.U. National Superintendents of Kindergarten Work after Mrs. E. G.
Greene, and by 1924 this department no longer existed. (32) From the time when
Mrs. Greene began kindergarten work for the W.C.T.U. the American concept of
kindergarten evolved into its being a function of the public school system
rather than of private schools.
1895
ÒMrs. E. G. Greene, who has been lecturing in the
northern part of the State for nearly a month, has returned to her home on
Mission street.Ó (33)
Church and Civic Activities
Mary J. Greene had entirely too much energy to
confine it to her role in the W.C.T.U.
While she lived in Santa Cruz she provided leadership in the
Congregational Church and in civic affairs, as shown by the following
chronology. Once again the list is
made from snippets of information, and, clearly, much could be added to it.
1887
Mrs. E. G. Greene was a member of the District
Committee of District Six of the Improvement Society, the task of which was to
work so that ÒSanta Cruz be freed from all blemishes and her natural beauty
enhanced by all that art and industry can do.Ó (34)
1890
The Kindergarten on Mission Street charged a small
fee and had a fund for those who were not able to pay. It was preparing the operetta ÔLittle
Red Ridinghood.Õ In a brief
newspaper article mentioning the kindergarten and praising it Mrs. Greene asked
the public to show greater interest in it. (35)
In December The Daily Surf printed Mrs. GreeneÕs ÒA
School House on Every Hilltop,Ó an impassioned plea for people to attend a
meeting on the importance of the public schools. The meeting was to be held at the Congregational church,
where Prof. Clark was to speak on ÒThe Home, the School, and the Nation.Ó (text
of article in appendix)
1891
In a public meeting the Santa Cruz Lecture
Association was formed. ÒIts
purpose shall be to maintain a course of lectures and entertainments of an
educational character.Ó Among the
approximately 20 persons signing the constitution were Mr. and Mrs. E. G.
Greene. Mrs. Greene was one of an
ad hoc committee of three who drew up the constitution. (36)
Among the set of officers elected September, 1891 to
succeed the previous, original, officers of the Santa Cruz Congregational
ChurchÕs WomanÕs Home Missionary Society, Mrs. E. G. Greene was elected
Secretary. (37)
1893
The Home Missionary Society and the Foreign
Missionary Society of the Santa Cruz Congregational Church merged, and Mrs. E.
G. Greene was elected President. (38)
1885-1899 Mr. E. G. GreeneÕs Activities
Although the present article is primarily about Mrs.
E. G. GreeneÕs presence in Santa Cruz, her husband, Mr. E. G. was better known
locally, and was, indeed, considered one of the prominent businessmen of the
city. News about him from
contemporary sources provides some background and contrast for the news about
his wife. One type of information
about him which is not available about Mary J. is the physical description
provided by the Great Register, Santa
Cruz County 1892: ÒGreene, Edward G. 5Õ10Ó, Fair, Blue eyes, light hair,
born in Vermont, res: 347 Mission st, 6th precinct, SC.Ó
1887
Recently returned from a business trip of several
months in New England, E. G. Greene was interviewed by the Surf concerning Santa CruzÕs future as a destination for eastern
immigration. He was enthusiastic
about the potential of Santa Cruz, but he thought more publicity was needed. (39)
1891
E. G. Greene was one of the seven original directors
of the newly incorporated Santa Cruz, Garfield Park, and Capitola Electric
railway. (40)
As noted above, in a public meeting the Santa Cruz
Lecture Association was formed. Both Greenes were among the approximately 20 persons signing
the constitution. Mr. Greene was among those representing Òthe
commercial world.Ó Mrs. Greene,
however, was one of the committee
which drew up the associationÕs
constitution. (41)
1892
Elected to the City of Santa Cruz Common Council, Mr.
E. G. Greene began his two-year term.
He was on the Council until 1894. (42) When the Common Council had to vote on permitting
electification of the Pacific Avenue horsecar line Greene abstained because he
was a stockholder in this railroad. (43)
1894
In February Mr. E. G. Greene informed the Surf that March 3 would be ÒVermont DayÓ
at Santa CruzÕs Midwinter Fair.
Present were to be over one hundred Vermonters, as well as Governor
Fuller and ÒLieutenant-Governor Stranahan of St. Albans, an old friend of Mr.
Greene.Ó (44)
1896-1898
E. G. Greene sold many of the lots he had carved out
of the old Wright property and a property he had acquired between Mission and
King Streets west of Laurel Street.
Two of the lots west of Laurel he sold to his wife. (45)
1897
In May the Daily
Surf carried a front page glowing report on the prospect for success of the
Junction Mine, a property near GrantÕs Pass, Oregon, apparently containing 50 acres
of gold bearing gravel, owned by E. G. Greene and D. Younglove of Santa Cruz. Capital was to be needed to construct
the water supply for the hydraulic extraction of the mineral. (46)
1898
In the November elections E. G. Greene was the
Democratic & PeopleÕs Party candidate for County Treasurer. On October 31 and November 4 and 7 the Daily Surf printed information about him
as well as his campaign statement and its endorsement of him. On November 9, the day after the
election, the Surf carried the
election returns: ÒREPUBLICANS MADE A CLEAN SWEEP.Ó None of GreeneÕs party won
any office in this election, but the candidate who was the most severely
trounced was Greene himself.
The Greenes and the Wrights depart from Santa Cruz
1892
Frances Matilda Wright of 347 Mission Street, age 15,
born in Canada, died in February. (47)
1898
William Wright of 347 Mission Street, age 84, born in
Scotland, died in April, 1898. E.
G. Greene paid for the burial. (48)
1899
ÒThe tri-county-Santa Cruz, San Benito and
Monterey-was obliged to elect a new president, Mrs. E. G. Greene, who had served
them long and well, having removed to another county.Ó (49)
1903 Edward C. [sic] Greene, formerly of Santa Cruz,
was residing in Palo Alto. (50)
1906
An advertisement for Mrs. E. G. GreeneÕs book Golden Keys in The Kindergarten Magazine and Pedagogical Digest, November, 1906
stated that Mrs. GreeneÕs address was St. Albans, Vermont. I have not pursued records concerning
Mrs. GreeneÕs last years and death.
1909
Edward Griswold Greene died. (51)
NOTES
1 Harrison,
History of Santa Cruz County p. 359,
where she is called Mary Jean. In the U. S. Census of 1880 she was Jane, and in the deeds to property in
Santa Cruz she was Mary J. Much as I would like to refer to her in
this article as Mary J. Greene to emphasize her independence from her husband,
the consistency with which she was known as Mrs. E. G. Greene in Santa Cruz, in
St. Albans, and wherever else she went counsel me as a rule to use Mrs. E. G. Greene. That her mother was Jerusha Wright
appears from the enumeration of the Wright family in the 1870 U. S. Census
2 Harrison,
History of Santa Cruz County p. 359
3 Harrison,
History of Santa Cruz County p.
358. The IGI Individual Record gives the birth date as May 11, 1835. Where there is discrepancy about the
facts, with due respect to the genealogists who present information about
Greene in the IGI Individual Record
and in the website, shadesofthedeparted.com 2009, I follow HarrisonÕs History of Santa Cruz County because
Harrison presumably took his information directly from Greene. The confusion about the year and day of
GreeneÕs birth evidently arises from the coincidence that in 1860 there were
two young Edward Greenes in St. Albans, one born in 1834 and the other in
1835. Both were clerks in
(different) stores and both lived in the household of the storeÕs proprietor
according to the 1860 U. S. Census.
Born in 1834 was ÒE. G. Greene,Ó and born in 1835 was ÒEdward Green.Ó)
4 IGI Individual Record
5 EbenezÕr
Allen, History of Franklin and Grand Isle
Counties, Vermont. Syracuse,
N. Y.: 1891, p. 323
6 Harrison,
loc. cit.
7 IGI Individual Record
8 U.
S. Census, where her name is spelled Pheba
9 A Centennial History of St. Albans, Vermont,
pagination unclear
10 Harrison,
History of Santa Cruz County p. 358
11 Harrison,
History of Santa Cruz County p. 359
12 ibid.
13 Gordon, Women Torchbearers, p. 298
14 Union Signal, Oct. 22, 1885
15 Santa Cruz County Museum of Art
& History Evergreen Cemetery records
16 Map:
Santa Cruz Surveyed by Foreman & Wright 1866
17 Chase,
Sidewalk Companion, p. 235
18 Santa Cruz County Museum of Art
& History Evergreen Cemetery records
19 ÒFrom
notebook w/Hecox Tilden effectsÓ in Santa Cruz County Museum of Art & History
Evergreen Cemetery file
20 S.C. Sentinel, June 19, 1885
21 Santa
Cruz County Deeds, Book 48 Page 428, Book 49 Page 274, Book 53 Page 30; Book 57
Page 103
22 Daily Surf, August 8, 1889. Unfortunately the writer of the SurfÕs article thought that William was
the brother who had died, and that Mrs. E. G.Õs mother came with her, although
the 1880 U.S. Census shows that her father was a widower at that time.
23 Undated
clipping – with a photo - ÒFrom The Preston Sawyer CollectionÓ in an
unidentified newspaper in Santa Cruz County Museum of Art & History
Evergreen Cemetery file
24 Paul
Tutwiler, Santa Cruz Spirituality.
Santa Cruz: 4th ed., 2009, Chapter 5, ÒParticulars: WomanÕs
Christian Temperance UnionÓ
25 Union Signal, Sep. 22, 1887 and June 1,
1899
26 Daily Surf, Sep. 20, 1886
27 Daily Surf, March 17, 1887
28 Union Signal, Sep 22, 1887
29 The Kindergarten for Teachers and Parents,
June, 1888
30 The Kinderegarten for Teachers and Parents,
loc. cit.
31 Harrison,
History of Santa Cruz County, p. 359
32 Gordon,
Women Torchbearers, p. 298
33 Daily Surf, Sep. 11, 1895
34 Daily Surf, August 6, 1887
35 Daily Surf, March 31, 1890
36 Daily Surf, Aug. 28, 1891)
37 Witness, p. 95
38 Witness, p. 97
39 Daily Surf, August 20, 1887
40 McCaleb,
Surf Sand & Streetcars, p. 39
41 Daily Surf, Aug. 28, 1891
42 www.santacruzpl.org/history/articles/325
2009
43 McCaleb,
Surf Sand & Streetcars, p. 42
44 Daily Surf, Feb. 26, 1894
45 Santa
Cruz County Deeds, Book 105, Page 72, Book 110 Page 186, Book 123 Page 232;
Book 127 Pages 30 and 40
46 Daily Surf, May 19, 1887
47 Santa
Cruz County Museum of Art & History Evergreen Cemetery file
48 Santa
Cruz County Museum of Art & History Evergreen Cemetery file
49 Union Signal, June 1, 1899
50 McCaleb,
Surf Sand & Streetcars, p.
112. I have not been able to check
this with documents of the period.
51 FamilySearch
International Genealogical Index v5.0.
This source has no further details about the place or circumstances of
his death.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
EbenezÕr Allen. History of Franklin and Grand Isle Counties,
Vermont. Syracuse, N. Y.:
1891.
A centennial history of St. Albans, Vermont. Published for the St. Albans Board of Trade, 1889;
copy used is in www.archive.org 2009, scanned from a copy in the New York
Public Library.
A Century of Christian Witness: History of First
Congregational Church, Santa Cruz, California. Santa Cruz: Church Historical Committee, 1963.
Foreman & Wright,
Surveyers. ÒSanta Cruz Surveyed by
Foreman and Wright 1866.Ó
Elizabeth Putnam Gordon. Women Torch-bearers: The Story of the
WomanÕs Christian Temperance Union. Evanston, Illinois, National WomanÕs
Christian Temperance Union Publishing House, 1924.
E. S. Harrison. History of Santa Cruz County, California.
San Francisco: Pacific Press Publ. Co., 1892.
Great
Register, Santa Cruz County 1892.
IGI Individual Record,
FamilySearch International Genealogical Index v5.0.
Charles S. McCaleb. Surf
Sand & Streetcars: A Mobile History of Santa Cruz, California. Santa
Cruz: History Museum of Santa Cruz County, 1995.
Santa Cruz County Deeds.
Santa Cruz County Museum of Art & History Evergreen Cemetery records.
Santa Cruz Daily Surf
Santa Cruz Sentinel.
Paul Tutwiler, Santa Cruz Spirituality. Santa Cruz: 4th
ed., 2009
The
Union Signal:
official journal of the WCTU. Evanston, Illinois: Signal Press.
United States Census Enumeration, St. Albans,
Vermont, 1860, 1870, and 1880.
www.santacruzpl.org/history/articles 2009
APPENDIX.
BOOKS AND ARTICLES BY MRS. E. G. GREENE
Books
Pathfinders for the organization and work of the
WomanÕs Christian Temperance Union. New
York: National Temperance Society and Publication House, 1884, 184 pages.
Golden
Keys, The Kindergarten out of School. Chicago: WomanÕs Temperance
Publication Association, 1888, 91 pages.
Articles (full texts)
SANTA
CRUZ KINDERGARTEN CLASS
(From The Union
Signal, April 8, 1886)
The Santa Cruz Union have organized a Kindergarten
class. At their first meeting a
talk was given by the National Superintendent on work of class.
The lesson was on the doctrines and methods of
educators in different nations.
Extracts were read from PayneÕs History of Pedagogy (published by Heath
& Co., Boston [in 1885]), and on the following [Ernst] SteigerÕs tracts: ÒWhat
is the Purpose of the Kindergarten?Ó ÒFroebel and the Kindergarten System.Ó ÒThe
Genesis of Froebelism.Ó ÒThe
Medical Profession Recommend the Kindergarten,Ó ÒFroebelÕs First Gift for Babies.Ó Also extracts from [Edouard] SeguinÕs Report of Education
and Methods of Teaching, and Philosophical training of Children.
Discussion of various topics followed the reading.
The second meeting of the class was a quiz on the
readings of the previous meeting.
The following is the list of the questions used:
1. How
does the ideal of the perfect man affect education of a people?
2. Give
a brief account of French pedagogy.
3. German.
4. What
causes fluctuation in educational systems?
5. Mention
some things which affect educational systems.
6. Mention
distinctive features of Hindoo system.
7. Buddhist.
8. Israelites.
9. Romans.
10. Athenian.
11. Spartan.
12. How
did Renan think probably Christ learned to read?
13. What
place did Aristotle and Plato accord to music?
14. How
were the laws of Greece promulgated?
15. Mention
some of the peculiarities of SocratesÕ method of teaching.
16. What
place in the education of the individual did Plato give to the soul?
17. What
did St. Jerome say regarding the education of girls?
18. What
did Charlemagne give to education?
19. Give
history of the founding of the Kindergarten by Froebel.
20. When
does education begin?
21. Do
the medical authorities recommend the Kindergarten?
22. Mention
some special action of the Medical Society.
The third meeting is to be a review of the last from
the notes taken by the class.
Extracts will be read from ÒThe Laws of ChildhoodÓ and ÒThe Child,Ó also
a talk on the use of the ball (the first gift).
Much interest was manifested by the members. Great stress was laid upon the thought
that education for children should be physiologically obtained. The motherÕs training should be the
beginning of this application of physiological principles, then she must desire
it to continue when she places her child in the school, and will therefore work
for the physiological training of teachers. Seguin says: ÒWhen the school shall be taught by women and
controlled by physiologists, a child will not enter it like cattle a corral;
only, being counted in again, do not touch these unknown quantities of vital
activity, called children, before you have taken the bilan of the forces of
each, so that what can be spent and what spared of his vitality of caloric
during the combustive process of educational labors, might be measured as
mathematically as the quantity of coal to run an engine.Ó
ÒTo defend their countries the Austrian the
Frenchman, the Prussian, the Russian, keep under arms in idleness 500,000 or
more young men. To protect ours
against its only enemy, bigoted ignorance, we must have an army of 500,000
young girls, teaching our children in squads of twenty and preparing themselves
for the duties of motherhood, so much higher than those of paternity.Ó
ÒTo Salvandy belongs the honor of having officially
said that the teaching of the people needs to be organized.Ó Why should not the W.C.T.U., the
grandest organization of women in the world, step at once into its right place
in the American educational system.
Its members are students of heredity and of hygiene, and are fitting
themselves to understand the practical application of their knowledge, and the
next place where duty naturally follows is in the development of the child as
taught by the Kindergarten; why may they not be the school and home
physiologists?
ESSENTIAL
EDUCATION FOR WOMEN
(From The
Kindergarten for Teachers and Parents, May, 1888, pp. 83-85)
Miss Peabody rightly says, ÒTo be a Kindergartner is
the perfect development of womanliness—-a working with God at the very
fountain of artistic and intellectual power and moral character. It is therefore the highest finish that
can be given to a womanÕs education to be educated for a Kindergartner.Ó What a responsibility rests upon the
Kindergartner, and how great the significance of her office—-Òa working
with God.Ó
What an advance this marks in the education of
women. The Kindergartner herself
must possess this development of womanliness, this Òfinish,Ó this Òall aroundÓ
education. She must not only
understand the manipulation of the Gifts, have a full knowledge of the history
of education, and FroebelÕs principles, but this ÒdevelopmentÓ which she would
bring to the child must be hers, as
well. Would she attract other
young women to this work and have them share with her the blessedness, she must
become all that it is Òto be a Kindergartner.Ó
I like Miss PeabodyÕs definition, there is nothing
exclusive about it. It seems to mean, whosoever will, let him come. I am so glad it does not say, that no
one can possess it who has not been through a college course, and that it also means that the most thorough
course of education needs just this finish. Nor does it imply that this education is confined to sex,
but whosoever, whether man or woman possesses it has gained a fitting work, Òthe
very fountain of artistic and intellectual power and moral character.Ó
What a source of power, and how every true
Kindergartner ought to desire it for young women, and not only desire it but
work to bring a knowledge of the system to them. There needs to be a real bond of womanhood between those who
understand what this work means for women and children; what it means for home
and society; what it means for the young women. To them it is lifeÕs richest boon; all true Kindergartners
know what this work has done for them —- what a revelation of themselves
they have received as they have studied the child. What an immense power this education would be if possessed
by all who work in any way for childhood.
The mother-heart of the world is stirred, the life-work of woman is
claiming a large share of her thought.
Here is the one sphere which is so clearly indicated by nature that no
one has arisen to dispute womanÕs right to it —- her illimitable
influence in the character-forming of childhood. This is more and more apparent. Heredity has discovered the effect of ignorance of the
simplest laws of life upon the health and character of the race. It has passed into a proverb,
that whatever we would have appear in the character, must be built into
it. Thus since womanÕs work is
largely dealing with character-building, how very important it is, then that
all things connected with the care and trainng of children should receive
attention. The Kindergarten not
only qualifies for early child training, but also prepares the parent to assume
the whole training, with the help of the teacher during a few hours of the day;
the remaining hours being so arranged that the life, in and out of school,
forms one harmonious whole. Here
the elder sister also finds ample scope for using her Kindergarten training,
and in the Primary Sunday-school class, where she may wisely deal with the
spiritual natures of the little ones which now so largely dominates their
life. For in those early days the
image of the Father shines out most clearly and she carefully strengthens this
budding grace of childhood that it may in time grow into a consciousness of the
grand truth that ÔIn Him we live and move and have our being.Õ The primal days of life are becoming
the most dearly prized, the golden
opportunity, the rooting time for principles. Oh, girls, with time and talent who can choose your life
work,-- would you set it far away from childhood? Nay, build no palaces where the merry laughter of children
shall not be heard. Come with us
and learn all that this blessed gospel of education holds for you.
If I am able to read the prophecy manifest on every
hand, it is, that the time is ripe for a
step forward in this work, a real shoulder to shoulder onward march.
This century will place the early education of the
child where it belongs, and woman will take her place as the acknowledged
educator. This necessary training
for her natural vocation will be considered an essential part of every womanÕs
education. Whatever may be left
out of education, this greatest of sciences will receive attention, and be
deemed essential not only to all women,
but to all men. We shall require no less of physiology,
of mental and moral science or of philosophy; nothing less of botany, of
rhetoric, of all that intellect or heart can bring; only added to this will be
education child-ward. Only let
this love which cradles infant life be more wise, and set forth more truly the
type of the Divine.
Let the early, delicate, helpless days of life be
guarded from inexperienced care-takers, and let all who come to this sacred
trust have special training for their work. Let them learn the secret of true education, which is
preserving the harmonious balance of the faculties, and also that right
beginnings are of immeasurable importance. Hence no effort should be spared to bring the knowledge of
the Kindergarten to young women; it belongs to them, it is their heritage; their
profession. I would ask no better
dower for any young woman than this training. What a safeguard from trials incident to ignorance, what a
meaning it gives to human life, what a responsibility in shaping and controlling
human forces. How the training and
teaching of children would deepen in importance; how the motherÕs mission would
be elevated into a sacred trust; how noble would be laid the foundation of
family life; how the purity of social life would admust itself. There would indeed be ÒSermons in
stones and books in running brooks.Ó
The harmonies of life could set about the soul at its coming-— and
no rude, base passion would control the destinies of man. There are scores of young women ready
for this training. But a few
practical questions always confront them.
The expense? The leaving home: Is there lack of employment when trained?
The value of this education is such, that as rapidly
as possible the way ought to be made very plain for those who desire to take
the training. To arouse more interest
in this education and thus create a demand for Kindergartners is an excellent
way to solve the question, ÒWhat shall we do with our daughters?Ó Woman holds the solution of this
question in her hands to-day. To
her kingdom belong those subjects over which church and state had bitter
controversy. How little do we
appreciate our power to form the characters of the world. Horace Mann says: ÒI have no firmer
belief than that a wise womanhood could take the race in its arms as a mother
takes her babe, and shield it from harm, nurse it into immortal strength and
beauty, and train it into such a glorious manhood as should be worthy [of] its
nature and its Author.Ó
Froebel says: ÒMany a young man would have known how
to be useful, would not have lost his power in the bloom of his youth, if his
parents or teachers had followed in his education the principles laid down in
my book for mothers.Ó
The beautiful, healthy young wife of Froebel gave her
whole soul, her efforts and her money, to assist him in his work for the
Kindergarten, into which he entered with almost unparalleled zeal and devotion,
bringing to it all his knowledge of the sciences, of several languages, and of
education. His life was spent in
search for a better education for childhood,
over whose temple he read, ÒOf such is the Kingdom of heaven,Ó an education,
which would give to the child from the start, the riches of this Kingdom, which
are his due.
This is the education which he leaves as a legacy to
the young men and women who are ready to enter into possession. The appeal which more than fifty years
ago Froebel sent out to the women of Germany, has gathered more force with the
years, and comes to the women of America with more of hope than to any other
people.
The universal educating power of women is recognized,
and there remains the duty of bringing to all a knowledge of the first
principles of education. This task
demands the attention of every woman.
THE
KINDERGARTEN AND THE SUNDAY SCHOOL
(From The
Kindergarten for Teachers and Parents, October, 1888, pp. 180-182)
The Kindergarten is the most adequate system for the
religious nurture of childhood, therefore it can readily attach itself to every
work which deals with the spiritual nature of the child. It is eminently adapted to the
Sunday-school and should go hand in hand with it.
The child is a growing human plant, possessed of a
God-likeness, capable of development.
Educators are the gardeners to whom is entrusted the
culture of this priceless immortal being.
At the very outset it is essential that the conditions to be met shall
be fully recognized, the first of which is orderly doing for the child and by
the child.
Order is the key-stone of character, Òthe sanity of
the mind, the health of the body, the peace of the city, the security of the
state.Õ Second, there must be
continuity of effort. Third, and
all-embracing, there must be unity.
These requirements are the foundations upon which education should rest in
home, church, school and state.
The threefold nature of the child must be trained
into equipoise. The health of the
body, the vigor of the intellect, the spontaneity of the soul must together
govern the conduct.
This is the work of the Kindergarten, and it looks
hopefully toward the Sunday-school, as a co-worker in this complete
education. In many respects union
between these two forces is already practicable, but much study and
co-operative effort is still needed before a desirable fusion an be obtained.
The Sunday-school holds the golden opportunity for
the spiritual culture of the child, which there brings to the teacher its best
self, seeking nourishment. A
willingness, nay, a desire to be led into ways of pleasantness and paths of
peace characterizes these early days. The child believes in the Sunday-school.
Its teachings and its loving influence are to him the law and the gospel
regulating life. The Bible is the
treasured book. The stories of
Joseph, of David, of Samuel, of Esther, of the little Syrian maid, charm the
imagination and move the heart.
The Sunday-school relates itself to the child more
tenderly, takes it more lovingly by the hand, draws it more closely to the
heart, and holds it nearer and dearer, than any institution outside of the
home. Thus it wins the little
soul, nestling restfully in this peace-giving shelter, and life bids fair to
set in at its best. The love of
the parent, the love of the church, the love of the Sunday-school, foreshadow
and personate to the child the love of the Heavenly Father, of which we desire
him to become conscious in order that he may strive to become Godlike. Our love must manifest itself not alone
in words, not along in song and story, but in an endeavor to know and meet the
wants of child nature.
Character has stages of development. In workng with the childish mind the
perceptive faculties must be the medium for approach. Every sense is on the alert. The lessons must appeal to these, and over against every
truth must be placed suggestive and practical applications, mindful of the laws
of spiritual and intellectual growth.
Remembering that we both learn and grow by the doing,
we would turn their activities into the leverage of good works, we would aid
them in gaining their redeemed estate,
and give to their whole natures free play, that the wounds of ancestral poison
may be healed, and evil eliminated from their lives.
We would unload poor little humanity of its burden of
sins, in His name who purchased their freedom and bind it with golden chains
close to the heart of God.
The harmony of song, touching the chords of being,
and connecting the child with life about him, may be woven around, and about
all, ever keeping the Father in the midst, and the loving tender Jesus who
blessed little children and took them in his arms.
In order to carry out the purpose of the
Sunday-school, and to make its work most effective in awakening the soul to the
indwelling consciousness of God, we must set aside the thought that the Infant
Class is a miniature Bible Class.
The great need is to prepare the mind for the
reception of truth. This done, we
may wisely plant the seed and nourish it, watching its growth. Let us come down to the simplicity of
the little child, and then enter readily with him into the Kingdom of Heaven —-
Christ himself, the great teacher, said, ÒExcept ye become as little childen,
ye cannot enter the Kingdom of Heaven.Ó
The sacredness of the Sabbath can be infused into
every occupation which we would give to a child that day. The loving Father would not have us
unduly check the liveliness and playful nature which he has implanted. But he would have us train children to
exercise on that day even more than usual of gentle, loving thought toward each
other, and an uplifting of heart in their Heavenly Friend in whatever they do. The Kindergarten Gifts are symbols of
GodÕs truth expressed in form and color.
Their use is so well adapted to meet the growing nature of the child, to
call out its faculties, to develop its physical, intellectual and spiritual
nature, that it is only a question of time when the tiny tables and chairs of
the Kindergarten will find their way into the Sunday-school, and well-directed
play lessons will illustrate to the little ones the sacred truths for which the
Sunday-school is instituted.
The parable of the sowers, and indeed all of the 13th
chapter of Matthew are rich in lessons for this Christian work.
Christ said to his disciples, ÒMany prophets and
righteous men have desired to see these things which ye see, and have not seen
them; and to hear these things which ye hear, and have not heard them.Ó In closing his lesson he asks, ÒHave ye
understood these things?Ó
ÒEvery scribe which is instructed into the Kingdom of
Heaven is like unto a man which is a householder, which bringeth forth his
treasures new and old.Ó
What we now need is not more study of new methods,
but more study of the child; a better realization that we are GodÕs
interpreters, not alone of truths held in words, but of those written from the
beginning in our hearts and all around us. Would that every Sunday-school worker be brought into
contemplation of the child and his relation to it and to God! Then we
should see such a turning to the principles and methods of the Kindergarten, as
would illumine the pathway from the cradle to the cross.
A
SCHOOL HOUSE ON EVERY HILLTOP
(From the Daily
Surf, Dec. 11, 1890)
Yes, and on every barren plain and lowly valley this
child of progress will find its way.
Wherever the children are, there goes this college for rich and poor
alike. Who can imagine a city
without its public schools, where boys only are gathered into the parish
schools for instruction, and little girls, poor things, can neither read nor
write?
Do we sufficiently esteem our glorious
privileges? Do we rally for our
childrnÕs sake, wherever the interests of education are conserved? Do we value the factors which make up
the sum of advantages for our children?
Do we encourage the teachers; do we show them that we desire the unity
of school and home? Do we cherish
the interest of education as a part of the cityÕs advancement?
Verily the ring of the school bell opens the door of
every household wherever the little six-year-old is found, the thought and good
will follows the pupil; the household machinery is adjusted to run without
friction in harmony with the schools; hand in hand the silent partner goes, day
in and day out; wearily the mother toils, and the father, if needs be, wears
the old coat, that the year at the high school may be accomplished. We are proud of our public schools. We may well be. Will not the interest in this beloved
institution fill the Congregational church tonight to hear what Prof. Clark has to say on ÒThe Home,
the School, and the Nation?Ó
THE
SCHOOL OF METHODS. NOTES
CONCERNING THE SUMMER SESSION FOR TEACHERS AND KINDERGARTNERS.
(From the Daily
Surf, July 30, 1891)
The following items have been kindly furnished the
SURF by Mrs. E. G. Greene, who was herself one of the corps of teachers at the
Summer School of Methods.
The California Summer School of Methods for teachers
and kindergartners was held in the State Normal School building, San Jose, from
July 6th to the 26th.
The interest and enthusiasm of the teachers in the work of the school
and their frequent expression of delight at the opportunities afforded, were
evidence of the success of the school (in its second year). There were thirty students enrolled, from
fifteen counties reaching from Humboldt to Los Angeles -— teachers from
all grades of public school work.
There were in all, twenty instructors. Five of the classes went through the
entire three weeks, namely: History of Education, Psychology, Primary Science,
Kindergarten and Normal Training.
The other classes continued one week. The majority of the instructors were from the Normal School,
hence the classes had the great advantage of the use of apparatus and
appliances under the guidance of teachers at home in the class rooms; every
effort on the part of the several instructors was made to give the classes the
most and the best possible in the short time allowed. The aim of each was to give some practical work as well as
teach the principles upon which it was founded.
In the ÒHistory of EducationÓ Prof. McGrew dealt with
some of the leading educators, whose influence is felt today in our educational
work, Comenius, Pestolozzi [sic], Froebel, also a few of the educators in our
own country, and the growth of education.
In Psychology he took the Human Intellect and its development,
emphasizing how ideas are formed, the faculties acting to join ideas, the
office of the will, sensation, memory imaginationÓ [sic] in the growth of the
mind. Each member of the class
received a blank, calling out their observations in the study of the child,
inciting them to further study of children and the reflex study of themselves,
thus this seemingly abstract study became a live study and was enjoyed. Prof. ChildsÕ enthusiasm in the manual
training department, met a hearty response, the class delighted in their home
made apparatus, especially the solar microscope which they tested with
microscopic work; they expect to do practical work in the school rooms with it.
Prof. ChildsÕ visit to the east put him into thorough
sympathy with the ÒNew Education. We
learn through doing,Ó speaks from every room in the building. The plates used by him, with the
home-made stereopticon in the study of history, were several of them from
places of interest, which he had visited on his trip east. Professors Randall, Holway,
KleebergerÕs and PattonÕs classes were full of interest, also Mesdames Busch, Wilson
and SchollenbergerÕs, all leading towards the Manual Training Department in the
way of requiring apparatus.
Mrs. Wilson and SchollenbergerÕs work illustrated the
Kindergarten methods applied to primary work, and was an excellent illustration
of the methods reading, observation lessons clay moulding and study of plant
life, [sic] Miss Gilday did excellent work in physical culture.
The Kindergarten work was entered upon with much
earnestness by a wide awake class who felt the necessity of understanding the
principles and methods of the Kindergarten in order to apply them to the
advance work. They were unanimous
in their decision that the Kindergarten should be the sub primary of the public
school. Many of the teachers are
allowed Kindergarten material for busy work in their schools. Practical work was done in language,
number, form and color. A study
was made of the first four gifts and the corresponding occupations. Work was developed from the solid to
the plane -— plane to line —- line to point, and illustrated by the
work of a class of children under Miss Bell McKenzieÕs kindergarten. Especial attention was given to
principals [sic] and theory, ÒFroebelÕs Mother—Play.Ó
The subject of color in the school room with the
class of children was illustrated by the relation of the song and story, also
the continuity of the work, running through the various lines of play, work,
the preparation for school work, for life before the child and the development
of life within the child, of the association of life about the child.
The sand table gathered up the work of the children
into a little picture of Farm and Country life as an illustration of the song, ÒCome
Little leaves, said the wind one day.Ó
The evening lectures by Mrs. Cooper, Prof. Dickinson,
Barnard, Dr.Õs Jordan and Sprague were of the highest order, very instructive
and enjoyable, appreciated by the small audiences who listened to them,
evidently San JoseÕs literary people were at the sea side or mountains and a
trip was made to Mount Hamilton and opportunity given for observation through
the telescope. The views along the
route up the mountain side and returning just at the break of day, with the
moonlight and the mist were beautiful beyond description.
The summer school closed with a delightful trip to
the Stanford University, the Palo Alto farm, a drive about Senator StanfordÕs
grounds.
Dr. Jordan, President of the University, welcomed the
school in person and explained the many interesting features of the various
buildings and the institution, so full of promise and possibilities. Every visitor can but feel an interest
and a desire to bring its advantages to many of the young people of the
coast. Several of the teachers
formed the resolution to return some time as pupils.
The farewells were spoken, the hand-shaking and
expression of pleasure in this Summer School were given and each went their
way, carrying the good will and pleasant memories, the stores of intellectual
and social gains, the satisfaction of a vacation of recreation and work.